Climate change Systemic risk Stress tests Valuation and portfolio optimisation

Mapping global financial risks under climate change

How much of a storm’s damage ends up in equity portfolios?

Antoine Mandel, Stefano Battiston and Irene Monasterolo trace floods, storms and wildfires from factories to security prices in “Mapping global financial risks under climate change”.

They geolocate ~130k facilities from 2,934 firms, simulate 1,000 hazard trajectories under various scenarios, and analyse the resulting structural credit risk for each issuer’s bonds and equity.

Their main conclusions include:

  • Under intermediate warming in 2050, hazards destroy 2.22% of productive capital per year on average and 3.8% at the 99th percentile.
  • Tropical cyclones and coastal floods are the most material hazards, ahead of river floods, winter storms and wildfires.
  • Mean equity losses range from 10.12% to 12.88% depending on baseline default risk, against 1.54% to 3.68% for one-year bonds, because equity absorbs shocks first.
  • Tails are heavier still, with a 99th percentile value at risk of 13.78% to 17.36% for the equity portfolio and 3.90% to 8.24% for bonds, and some issuers’ equity entirely wiped out.
  • Eastern Asia hosts 23.69% of exposed capital but bears 39.36% of impacts, while North America hosts 36.77% for only 22.04%, as cyclones and coastal floods concentrate on Asia.
  • Damage in eastern, southeastern and southern Asia is partly exported to firms headquartered in Europe, whose share of global equity impacts is about 3.4 times their share of direct damage.
  • Moving from today’s climate to high-end warming in 2080 raises average impacts by about 40% and adds up to 3% of equity losses and 80 basis points on bonds.

The paper challenges a home-bias reading of climate risk like European equity being exposed through Asian facilities, along with the costs missed when risk is priced using only past events.

Mapping borrowers’ production sites rather than relying on country averages using environmental scenario analysis will soon be part of banks’ ESG risks management through the EBA guidelines.

Correlations across hazards and locations are ignored, so direct losses are likely understated, while firm financials rely on sectoral averages and a uniform baseline default probability.